
When I was a lad, my brother and I had “comic books,” which I put in quotes because they were always the most off-brand, never-heard-of, outdated, cheap comics that cost less than a quarter an issue. While other kids were reading DC and Marvel comics, or maybe Archie or MAD, my brother and I were stuck with “Little Lulu,” “Dot,” and “Hot Stuff.” This last one was about some benign, cute devil (literally) who was always getting in trouble. And the cover each month had some lame gag about how he used his pitchfork or tail for some mundane, workaday task.

Anyway, I’m thinking about Hot Stuff because today’s drink is something called a Hell Fire. The name reminds me of something called a “Prairie Fire” that I had a few times on dares in college. It involves a healthy shot of 151 and a Tabasco floater.

But the Hell Fire is a little different. Once again, there are a number of drinks on the web that carry this name. but the one I’m making is from a recent issue of Town&Country, and involves (1) homemade grilled peach sherbet [please don’t mispronounce or misspell that word] and (2) real fire. What could go wrong?
The Recipe: Combine 2 oz bourbon, 3/4 oz lemon juice, and 3/4 oz grilled peach sherbet in a shaker. (The sherbet is made by grilling peaches, tossing them in a blender with an equal amount of sugar, and then freezing the concoction.) Strain into a glass, and garnish with fresh mint and ground cinnamon. Light the cinnamon on fire.
I should acknowledge that I had trouble getting the cinnamon to ignite. So, I added a little 151 (from my Prairie Fire days!) to the top, lit that on fire, and sprinkled on cinnamon. It provided a nice, sparkly effect. If anyone has a better suggestion for igniting cinnamon, I’m all ears.

The Ratings: Well, you really can’t beat the appearance. The drink itself is kind of rustic, with a viscous consistency, a seasonable pumpkin hue, and little black bits (seeds? Pieces of char?) swimming around. But the sparkling flames seem the ideal adornment for a Halloween drink. This deserves the full 4 points for appearance…but I’m only giving it 3.5 points, because the cinnamon wouldn’t light without the assistance of 151.
The taste is de-lic-ious! Admittedly, part of the reason is because I added 1/3 cup of sugar to the sherbet. But I only used a small amount of the total sherbet, so one drink probably only has a tablespoon or two of sugar. The grilled peaches are absolutely delectable–rich and flavorful and fruity. The bourbon lends the usual gravitas, with oak and spice and brown sugar. The lemon slightly attenuates all that sweetness. And as I mentioned earlier, the mouthfeel is full and rich, like a Jamba Juice. Four points for taste.
Hell Fire is a controversial choice for a name. It might be a little ungodly for some. But it definitely connects with the fire element that distinguishes the cocktail’s appearance. And Hell conjures up (hopefully not literally) devils, demons, death, and various other Halloween-esque elements. I feel obligated to give the name the full 2 points.
Grand Total: 9.5. I recommend you make yourself one of these drinks!Just consider using 151 instead of Maker’s bourbon.


















